Best bakery for cakes?

I'm looking for a great birthday cake this year and I'm wondering what are yalls favorite places for cakes? I have heard Costco makes a pretty decent cake, but I don't need to feed 48 people. I had two cakes from Moeller's bakery last year and I was severely unimpressed with it considering how expensive it was. Chocolate bar looks pretty good, but I don't want to spend $100 on a birthday cake. I also want a basic cake, not crazy fondant designs.