Over the past few months, I’ve been an avid Bryce Young supporter. I love the guy. Outside of size concerns, he’s got all the intangibles and just seems like such a class act that it’s hard not to want him on our team. Especially since as the last franchise QB was a piece of s**t. However, selling the farm to move up and get him would put us back further than anything else.
For starters, Casserio has a known bias against smaller quarterbacks. That, coupled with the fact that he knows well that this may be his last chance to draft for us, tells me that no one is not going to be worth us trading up for at one. Each pick needs to be methodical, especially in the first and second round.
That presents two options. The simplest option is that no one trades up for the Bears pick. They seem to want a large haul for the pick, but I don’t see how that’s feasible. The Bears realistically can’t afford to trade down to 4 or lower without risking potentially missing out on Carter and Anderson. The Colts seem to be the most likely option, but what do the Bears do if the Colts take Young, we take Carter, and the Cards take Anderson? Now they’re holding on to additional picks but at the expense of losing the 2 premier defensive players in the draft. The only feasible option to me, would be the Raiders trading Adams to move up, but why would the Raiders do that when they could likely get a better return for Adams elsewhere and take either a veteran QB in Free Agency or a flyer late? If the Bears aren’t willing to budge on their demands, they’ll likely take either Carter or Anderson begrudgingly. If that’s the case, we get Young at 2 and don’t have to give up anything.
Option 2 is the Bears do facilitate a trade with a team for the number 1 pick. Bryce Young goes off the board. If this is the case, I think you have to go BPA. I would personally select Will Anderson here. My logic being Christian Harris was performing well as last season progressed and would likely be able to help Anderson transition easily from college to the NFL. Plus Anderson strikes me as more versatile than Carter. I would then take a flyer in the mid-rounds with someone like Max Duggan or Hendon Hooker. I don’t think Richardson or Levis are worth taking at 12, and I can easily see neither of them being there at 33.
What I would do is sign a QB in the off-season and wait. If you go out and get Garropolo, Carr, Geno, Brissett, etc. and wait, then whether we get Young or Stroud at 2 or Hooker or Duggan in the mid-rounds, we would likely still see a noteworthy improvement at QB. No rush in getting a rookie to start Week One. Give them a few weeks to feel things out. Then, during the draft, I would call the Bears’ bluff. Let them know if they trade down that they’re going to pay for it by missing out on game-changing players.
I truthfully think that things will be fine. This off-season is going to be imperative for how this franchise builds its identity moving forward. Nick is looking for a long-term coach and a draft class that can work in tandem with last year’s rookies to pioneer a new direction for this team moving forward. These next few months will be very telling for this team, and I’m interested to see what we look like in a few months.