Watching back snippets of the Eagles game and reflecting on the entire season, I’m actually on the bullish side for Davis’ growth. That may be a minority opinion but I don’t see anything in particular that should suggest otherwise. People might complain about his pocket presence and accuracy but he’s gotten a lot better at the former and the latter is more of a consistency issue and that usually corrects with more experience.
Now I’ll go over some of what I think was good and bad:
The bad – first off all I think it’s important to stop attributing some of these sacks to Mills because they’re not all his fault. I mean there was so many times where the C got beat like a drum or Green got bullied and there was no where for Mills to run to. Not many guys are slippery enough to duck and dodge instant pressure. However, Mills still has times where he tends to chop his feet way too much and gets way too busy as he’s going through his reads. He had a pretty senseless play where he backed into a sack, just being unaware of his surroundings. The thing is, it’s getting to the point where it’s less of Mills’ fault but when stuff like this happens he’s going to get crucified for it anyways because it happens SO MUCH. Every now and then it’s genuinely his fault and he’s letting it pile on. Kind of why we shouldn’t have drafted a QB into this turd situation in the first place but oh well.
The bad #2- Ball placement is all over the place. I’m not worried about this long term, as I said I think this is something he can get way better at this off season and QBs tend to get more accurate over time. But right now he’s leaving TDs off the board with his ball placement. This is on him. He does it both when there’s pressure and when there isn’t. But he doesn’t do that every game. It’s mostly those intermediate to deep passes but at least he’s connecting and there’s a real chance he improves.
The bad #3- The turnovers/interceptions. First of all, I’ll credit that he hasn’t fumbled from his blind side recently. There was a play where Kenyon got bullied by HG and sacked Mills but Mills seemed to sense the pressure last second and as he was about to throw the ball he pulled it down. (There was no where for him to run so don’t tell me why didn’t he just run it.) However the interceptions have switched from being bad luck to blatantly his fault. The first couple interceptions felt like genuinely bad luck with tipped passes, etc. However the Raiders game was his worst interception yet. Just didn’t see the defender and was one of the first genuinely bad decisions he’s made in terms of where to go with the ball. This past Eagles game he threw 2. The first one was the fault of him and the OL. They again gave up instant pressure, just BAD- but Mills compounded on it. First he actually does a good job dodging the defender and stepping into space to throw and I think he was trying to put it in the dirt which is the right thing to do there BUT he needs to be more aware of what he’s doing. He panicked a bit and didn’t note CGJG who made a great play. The second interception was between him and the receiver. Again not on the same page (happening way too much) but also it was a forced ball. Even though the game was basically over I’d still prefer him not to turn it over. It just feeds the idea that he can’t be clutch which I don’t think is the case.
The good- many of you probably already stopped reading because some of you seem to want to crucify Mills for the sake of drafting Young or Stroud no matter what. Regardless of that, Mills has undeniably made progress in his pocket presence and ability to deliver the ball to all parts of the field. While ball placement is inconsistent, he has been overall sharp in decision making and execution, particularly in first halves. While this isn’t good enough, he’s also still surrounded by a flaming pile of garbage so I don’t attribute all the negative to him. To me he’s been the same Mills, just circumstances changes things in the second half. Anyways, he’s been a good decision maker, executing Pep’s offense with good timing. He could play faster on some plays for sure but as he gets more experience that’ll also work itself out I believe. Either way the fact remains that he’s outperformed lately given what he’s surrounded by and he needs to stack games like this. The Titans game was particularly rough because he didn’t have much help that game so it looked like pure regression. He needs to stack good performances here out and eliminate the turnovers, inconsistency narratives and narratives about inability to close games.
What really will be tested is his leadership. He needs to rally those guys to play for 4 quarters every game despite the lack of talent and guys checking out on the team.
Tldr- Mills gets a lot of blame for things that aren’t even his fault but he occasionally compounds things (albeit less so each week) which is setting up a narrative that he sucks. All his issues as an individual are realistically fixable and he’s already gotten better at some of them. He’s a solid decision maker and executing the offense better each week despite the talent around him. I think getting more weapons, Pep being a more consistent play caller, would actually sponsor the growth we want to see in Mills. There’s not really anything in his game to suggest otherwise to me.
Ok now bring on the hate comments. I’m not getting my blood pressure up arguing with you though. Just actually point out weaknesses in his game other than just saying he sucks and will never get better at things all QBs get better at.