Are the 1star companies worth the 0.5c to 1c saving per kWh versus the 4/5 star companies on powertochoose?

I’ve been searching daily for new rates on powertochoose. I’ve even searched Reddit for previous post and the logistics is go to powertochoose to pick the lowest rate.

My plan is up on two weeks, currently at 10c 2000kWh. Right now the lowest on powertochoose is around 11.7c for 12 months, non time of rate use.

I want to stick with higher rating companies, and the lowest is 12.5c 2000kWh with Constellation for 12 months. Are lower rated companies worth the 0.5c-1c savings? It’ll be $120 to $240 savings per year, but will I regret the hassle of dealing with the lower rated companies for the savings?